PicksInSix Review: Talley's Folly - Dunes Arts Summer Theatre
Lovers Reunite in Dune’s “Talley’s Folly”
PicksInSix® Review | Ed Tracy
The second production of the 2024 Dunes Arts Summer Theatre season is Lanford Wilson’s Pulitzer Prize-winning play “Talley’s Folly,” the second installment of Wilson’s Talley Trilogy that includes “Fifth of July” and “Talley and Son.” Released as a prequel to the critically acclaimed “Fifth of July” set in Wilson’s hometown of Lebanon, Missouri and chronicling the Talley family in 1977, the two other installments are set thirty three years earlier on the same day: July 4, 1944.
While “Talley and Son” plays out in the Talley homestead as a confrontation between generations about the future of the Talley family and is chronologically first in the trilogy, Wilson wrote and set “Talley’s Folly” in an isolated and decaying folly on the estate where Sally Talley (Amanda Tomczak), a young nurse, reunites with Matt Friedman (Rob Morris), a middle-aged Jewish accountant who returns to rekindle the romance of the previous summer and to propose marriage.
Directed at Dunes by Morgan McCabe, the two-hander unfolds over the course of ninety-seven minutes on an elaborate and impressive dockside set designed by Michael Lasswell with evocative lighting by Arturo Pozos. In the early evening, Matt awaits the arrival of Sally who has vigorously avoided him over the past year since their passionate liaison yet seeks him out. One might expect a more heartfelt reunion, but Sally’s abrupt and immediate admonishment comes as a shock to Matt. There are reasons for Sally’s behavior, we learn, as things progress. At the same time, Matt discloses the stunningly severe, inhumane treatment his family has endured as they fled Nazi oppression.
Early on, “Talley’s Folly” feels like an ill-fated love story, particularly as we discover the clash of Sally’s southern roots and Matt’s Jewish heritage. When the couple first met in the summer of 1943, the tide of the war had not yet turned so we are left to imagine the two lovers finding their emotional escape together within the fear of the time and isolation of the folly. That hopefulness, dashed by the family’s wholesale rejection of the affair, leaves only Matt’s dogged persistence to bring them back together.
Morris and Tomczak dive into these two challenging roles with gusto and there is a sense that their destiny is to escape together when all is done. Tomczak’s Sally is a strong, southern survivor whose life, shaped by fate, now offers few hopeful alternatives. In playing to the uneasy pressure and remorse to abide by her family’s wishes, Tomczak often overshadows the genuine love and affection that lies just beneath the surface and is desperate to reveal itself. Morris, whose lively character sets the tone of the piece, is effective in breaking through those emotional barriers to find common ground. And while satisfying, the production would benefit from the hint of playfulness that lovers have in such a secluded rendezvous to help elevate the humor in Wilson’s text while sustaining the moments of confrontation and drama in the piece as the two face the prospect of a challenging, post-war future together.
“Talley’s Folly” runs through July 14 at the Dunes theatre and is followed by “The Bridges of Madison County” with book by Marsha Norman and music and lyrics by Jason Robert Brown, directed by Dunes artistic director Steve Scott opening July 26.
PHOTO|Dunes Summer Theatre
Dunes Arts Summer Theatre
presents
Talley’s Folly
Michiana Shores, Indiana
through July 14
WEBSITE
TICKETS
For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago
PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC