PicksInSix Review: 2024 Year in Review

Tip The Hat. Turn The Page.
Memorable Performances for 2024
PicksInSix® Review | Ed Tracy

Singling out six of the most memorable performances of artists we covered in 2024 who turned heads and left lasting impressions long after the final bow was a daunting task. So difficult, in fact, that there is also special mention to others who have had terrific years on multiple Chicago stages.

It was a year that included the Royal Shakespeare Company’s return with “Pericles” at Chicago Shakespeare Company, pre-Broadway runs of “Death Becomes Her,” Steppenwolf’s “Purpose” directed by Phylicia Rashad—and, we expect, Sam Hunter’s “Little Bear Ridge Road,” a compelling new work starring Laurie Metcalf—and touring productions like the sensational “Harry Potter and The Cursed Child,” among others. While all deserving of mention, you will find others on the 2024 PicksInSix Year in Review list, our first post-pandemic yearend review.

A special note of thanks to every theatre company, their dedicated boards, administrative, artistic and technical teams, and the unending support of publicists who invest their time and talent in support of the Chicagoland theater community and made it possible to review these shows. It’s an honor to be invited and a responsibility that we take very seriously.

CONVERSATIONS|PicksInSIx® celebrates 10 years in 2025 and owes much to writers like Ronald Keaton, Scott Gryder and Kaitlyn Linsner who have contributed mightily to our archive of Chicago theatre during that time. Thank you!

And, a deserved tip of the hat to the brilliant Chicago theatre photographers Michael Brosilow, Liz Lauren, Brett Beiner, Joe Mazza and videographers HMS Media, among many others, whose expertise and professionalism continues to document these productions and preserve the image archive for future generations.

So here we go in alphabetical order and with a link to the PicksInSix Review (P6):

Sarah Bockel—Falsettos - TimeLine & Court Theatre - The critically-acclaimed co-production of director Nick Bowling’s “Falsettos” featured an ensemble of superb actors and singers in one of two sung-through shows on this list. In the role of Trina, Bockel delivered an extraordinary performance, navigating a delicate emotional path with heartfelt passion and homespun humor. Stunning! P6  

Mark David Kaplan—Fiddler on the Roof at Drury Lane Theatre - In the little town of Anatevka, director Elizabeth Margolius’s ‘memory play’ was, according to Kaitlyn Linsner, an opportunity for Kaplan to display “excellent comedic timing and whimsy” in the critically-acclaimed turn as Tevya. L'Chaim! P6

Beth Stafford Laird—FROZEN at Paramount Theatre - In an epic production directed by Trent Stork that includes several of Disney’s most popular songs and beloved characters, you just might take for granted a character whose youthful exuberance is at the heart of the story. The multi-talented Laird exudes unmatched charm in a rich performance as Anna that is marked by superb vocals, effortless company dance numbers and a shimmering presence all her own. Spellbinding! P6

Meghan Murphy—Anything Goes at Porchlight Music Theatre - Even a blizzard could not keep us away from director Michael Weber’s “Anything Goes” starring the captivating Meghan Murphy in a commanding performance as the seaworthy siren Sweeney. A topflight, take-no-prisoners, star turn. Anchors Away! P6

Aurora Penepecker—Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812 at Writers Theatre - The other sung-through musical/pop opera on this list—one of the most ambitious all-around artistic undertakings of the year by any theatre directed by Katie Spelman—featured an extraordinarily multi-talented ensemble of players. And there, at the center of this glorious production, was Penepecker whose lyrical voice and pristine talent was simply intoxicating. Magnificent! P6    

Sawyer Smith—Little Mermaid at Drury Lane Theatre - When you hear the term “over the top” in stage performances, it is often afforded to a performer who has elevated their role beyond the script and score to a new level of excellence. The showstopping turn for Smith, in the Scott Weinstein directed “Little Mermaid,” set a new standard that is certain to change the trajectory of Smith’s exceptional career. Wowza! P6

There are six other artists who excelled in multiple productions deserving of special mention: 

Jackson Evans displayed his wide range for musical comedy in four critically-acclaimed roles: Porchlight’s “Anything Goes,” Drury Lane’s “Guys and Dolls,” Paramount’s “Full Monty” and the Timeline/Court production of “Falsettos.” 

Heidi Kettenring delivered her special brand of star power to Drury Lane’s “Guys and Dolls,” Marriott’s “1776,” “Cinderella” and her concert performance of “Something Wonderful.” A true Chicago stage treasure!

We have been watching Evan Tyrone Martin for years and his compelling and beautifully sung Pierre in Writers “Comet” was central to the overwhelming success of this challenging production.

In addition to all of the projects the busy Ron OJ Parson has been delivering, Ronald Keaton noted that “East Texas Hot Links” at Court Theatre “bears the unmistakable stamp of the great director Ron OJ Parson, who has a relationship with this piece that forces us, in its sheer professionalism alone, to see an unencumbered view of what Jim Crow has done to our world and continues to do today.”

And as much as we never really give credit to the people who support everyone else, the masterful career of Nick Sula has been elevating the work of Sondheim enthusiasts throughout Chicago. Sula followed last season’s stellar production of “Kokandy’s Sweeney Todd” with the unique two piano presentation of Kokandy’s “Into the Woods.”  We can hardly wait to see what the next project will be.

Last, but not least, a tip of the hat to Charles Newell whose long-standing career as Artistic Director has come to a close at Court Theatre, You can be sure we have not heard the last from him. The Newell directed “An Iliad” starring Timothy Edward Kane returns in early June 2025. Bravo!

Happy Holidays!

See you on the other side of the aisle!

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

PicksInSix Review: Harry Potter and the Cursed Child - Broadway in Chicago

A THRILL-A-MINUTE BLOCKBUSTER ADVENTURE!
PicksInSix® Gold Review | Ed Tracy

Broadway in Chicago’s Nederlander Theatre is the first stop for the national tour of “Harry Potter and the Cursed Child” that had an epic premiere on Thursday, primed and ready for a long sit-down for the holiday season in Chicago that will no doubt fill every corner of Randolph and Dearborn with junior-level sorcerers with maroon and gold striped scarves and wands.

This is the final saga in J. K. Rowling’s spellbinding series of books that continue to engage readers of all ages, has spawned six epic films, and a hugely successful Broadway run garnering ten 2018 Tony Nominations winning six including Best Play. Following a Covid shutdown, the original two-part version was modified to one two-act play that has been retooled by one of the largest—and most celebrated—production teams ever assembled for the tour.

For anyone still wondering if this robust and heart-pounding show can do justice to all that has come before, rest assured that “Harry Potter and the Cursed Child” truly is a thrill-a-minute blockbuster adventure with all the magical twists and eye-popping special effects imaginable. It’s also an intriguing heartfelt story—filled to the brim with surprises that befit the original—written by Rowling, playwright Jack Thorne and director John Tiffany. Tiffany, with movement director Steven Hoggett, have assembled a superb cast to play new versions of the familiar characters that successfully tap into the memories of diehard fans who are sure to flock to this show, and are clever enough to captivate first timers and the young-at-heart from beginning to end. It’s a win-win all around!

To the story, it’s 19 years later. Harry Potter (John Skelley) and Ginny Weasley (Trish Lindstrom) are now married, as are Ginny’s brother Ron (Matt Mueller) and Hermione Granger (Ebony Blake), who is now serving as Head of the Ministry of Magic. Their children—Albus Severus Potter (Emmet Smith) and Rose Granger-Weasley (Naiya Vanessa McCalla)—board the Hogwarts Express where they meet Scorpius Malfoy (Aiden Close) son of Harry’s nemesis Draco Malfoy (Bejamin Thys). There is a dark cloud hovering over Scorpius and once at Hogwarts, the two form an alliance after being selected to Slytherin.

After meeting Amos Diggory (Larry Yando), the two join forces with his niece Delphi (Julia Nightingale) and plan to change the trajectory of the competition that ultimately cost the life of Amos’s son, Cedric Diggory (Caleb Hafen). Using a flurry of magical spells, the trio infiltrate the Ministry, abscond with the Time-Turner orb and are off on a race across time to save Cedric, only to realize that their impact on the past has a devastating effect on the present.

The fascinating arc of the story allows us to experience an exciting new adventure. The Dementors are here, along with Albus Dumbledore (the brilliant Yando who also plays Severus Snape), Moaning Myrtle (a delightful Mackenzie Lesser-Roy) and Professor McGonagall (Katherine Leask, who also shines as Professor Umbridge).

On the creative side, scenic designer Christine Jones uses massive arches to frame the Hogwarts action that then evolve seamlessly to establish other places and time periods. Among the many ingenious elements—including a plethora of magical entrances, high flying exits and cape-flashing scene changes—are the almost balletic use of twin stair units at Hogwarts and a delightfully carnivorous bookshelf. Imogen Heaps’s costumes are sensational. Neil Austin’s lighting and sound by Gareth Fry all complement Jamie Harrison’s astounding illusions that all contribute to a stunning, visual extravaganza.   

The message of love, family and friendship—and of good vs. evil—at the heart of this story courses through Skelley’s moving portrayal of Harry and in his relationship with his son. The younger clan form a union against the ever present dark arts to the extent that there feels like there could be much more to come in this franchise, despite Rowling’s assertion that this is Potter’s crowning achievement.

If that is the case, we will all have to join the next generation of adventure seekers and relive this series all over again. For the present, “Harry Potter and the Cursed Child” will be making magic every night at the Nederlander for all to see—a memorable holiday outing that will last well into the new year and beyond.

PHOTO|Matthew Murphy

Broadway in Chicago
presents
National Tour Debut
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
James N. Nederlander Theatre
through February 1, 2025

TICKETS

NATIONAL TOUR WEBSITE

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

PicksInSix Review: Back to the Future-The Musical-Broadway in Chicago

“It works. It Works. IT WORKS!”
PicksInSix® Review | Ed Tracy

It’s hard to avoid the what-if’s of time travel when it comes to the 1985 Robert Zemeckis film “Back to the Future” and its two sequels that have been entertaining audiences over the last 40 years. Jettisoning back along the space-time continuum to intentionally—or unintentionally—reorder events, change the future or restore balance to the universe has always been the stuff of classic science fiction storytelling.

The original “Back to the Future” was a real crowd-pleaser and a revelation for those of us around at the time. Sure, we had home movies, photo albums and family histories, but we could only imagine the past through the memories of those closest to us. Years from now, those memorable moments will be documented on a digital device in all formats, but obviously none of that existed when we were first introduced to a youthful rock n’ roller and his eccentric pal, the physicist who discovers a way to go back in time 1985 style. Taking the story from film to a live stage version creates some challenges and provides a splendid opportunity for eye-popping special effects.

At the opening of the national touring production of the John Rando directed “Back to the Future—The Musical” on Wednesday at the Cadillac Palace Theatre, I realized there was now a new generation introducing live theater to a much younger version as evidenced by a family of five sitting directly in front of me.  It was apparent to me that somewhere along the line I had taken for granted Doc Brown’s childlike wonder or the campy awkwardness of George McFly as he heroically confronts Biff in a parking lot, but not this crew.

For at least one of the three boys ranging in age from eight to mid-teen, this show was a first and they had a blast! Their joyous, wild enthusiasm for the extraordinary special effects and the techno star of the show—a slick, shiny DeLorean DMC-12 that makes a series of dramatic entrances and exits—was infectious. As avid young fans, their enjoyment was enhanced by the story as well because of its close proximity to the film and as a result, they followed along intently. And while we all know pretty much what was coming next, the Bob Gale book wisely stays within the margins and allows the stage version of “Back to the Future-The Musical” to evolve into a night of fun-filled family entertainment with more than enough whimsy and heart to wow the crowd.  

Or to borrow one of the Alan Silvestri/Glen Ballard lyrics sung by Doc Brown (a terrific role for Don Stephenson) when he first discovers proof of the viability of the flux capacitor: “It works. It Works! IT WORKS!” From Caden Brauch’s energetic portrayal of Marty McFly coaching the younger version of his dad George (a hilarious Burke Swanson) in “Put Your Mind To It” and the sultry Zan Berube’s rendition of “Pretty Baby” as the youthful Lorriane Baines in her bedroom with a trio of singers to Cartreze Tucker knocking the stuffing out of “Gotta Start Somewhere” as the young Goldie Wilson with the multi-talented ensemble and Stephenson’s blissful ballad “For the Dreamers,” this show has something for the young-at-heart of all ages.  But, oh that car is the real star!

When the original 2020 production was shut down in its first week due to the pandemic, you can bet that producers had no idea that four years later productions of “Back to the Future—The Musical” would be running concurrently in London, on Broadway and now in a 28 city national tour through August 2025. Safe to say that Marty, Doc and all the rest will be back in time well into the foreseeable future.       

PHOTO|Matthew Murphy & Evan Zimmerman

BROADWAY IN CHICAGO
presents
National Tour
BACK TO THE FUTURE—THE MUSICAL
Cadillac Palace Theatre
through September 1, 2024

TICKETS

SHOW WEBSITE

TOUR WEBSITE

BROADWAY IN CHICAGO

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

PicksInSix Review: The Kite Runner—Broadway In Chicago

“Kite Runner” poignant, moving… and shocking.
PicksInSix® Review | Guest Contributor | Ronald Keaton

If you’ve never read the bestselling novel The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini—a tale of friendship between two Afghan boys and how their choices dictate their adult lives—you are missing a real treatise in the nature of youth growing up. And as the audience was witness to the luscious theatrical take of the novel by Matthew Spangler, playing at Broadway in Chicago’s CIBC Theatre through June 23, it is striking how many of the themes that progress throughout the story are so universal and timeless, both in the family dynamic and inside us all as individuals. Friendship, betrayal, bigotry, sacrifice, courage (or lack of), there is an endless touch on all these ideas. It’s a stark lesson for all in Afghan culture and tradition that becomes highly accessible to all who invest in the storytelling, which, even in its challenges, is first rate and quite articulate.

The play opens atmospherically with a tabla player, offering some gentle, syncopated rhythm on his hand drum set, even as the audience enters the house.  Most of the story then revolves around the main character telling his side of things. His name is Amir, a comparatively well-to-do boy whose family has servants. One of the servants is Hassan, who serves Amir not only in deed but in their relationship as best friends. The separation between them is never really forgotten, it’s simply cast aside when convenient for the two boys to enjoy each other in growing up. There is an annual kite competition and Amir and Hassan enter it. It’s not a normal kite fight, so to speak. Contestants also have to run down the competition while in the air, last man standing. Amir feels special pressure from his father Baba to participate, since Baba senses that his sensitive son is not up to all the expectations that are placed in front of him. As the father did as a youth, Amir (with Hassan’s expert help) stunningly wins the competition and find at least a little compassion and respect in Baba’s house, even if it’s temporary.

Amir and Hassan are menaced by a gang of young thugs, whose claim on the prize for the kite competition was interrupted. That gang, in its continual harassment of the two friends, steals the magic blue kite that wins the prize and physically assault Hassan in the process while Amir watches helplessly.  Amir acquires a growing, lifelong guilt for not having stopped the violence, and Hassan is so loyal to his friend and master that he takes whatever punishment comes. In fact, the guilt is so strong that Amir simply denies the friendship any more influence and even tries to plant a theft under Hassan’s bed, so that he and his family will be banished. To Amir’s utter surprise, Hassan confesses to a crime he did not commit. And a bigger surprise comes when Baba forgives him—something that shapes the father/son relationship for the rest of their lives.  Eventually Hassan and his father leave the house in shame, taking with them a dreadful family secret owned by both fathers. In the meantime, the country is invaded by the Russians (the entire story all takes place between 1973-2001), and so Baba and his family need to leave for their own protection and come to America, specifically San Francisco. And this is just Act I.

From then on, the family becomes somewhat Americanized. Amir becomes the writer he always wants to be. He meets his future wife Soraya, a teacher in her own right. They want to have children but cannot conceive and consider adoption. Her father, a general back home, distastefully rejects such a notion because of a “blood” consideration—a bit like the old notion “but you don’t know where that’s been” in his regard for adoption. You know, purity of the bloodline and all. And at this point, Amir goes back to Afghanistan to discover the moment in his own life where guilt can at last be assuaged and shape itself into a kind of redemption. It’s a part of the story that one needs to witness to understand its impact. It’s abrupt and shocking and very personal. And quick, almost too much for some. But it works in a grandly affecting manner, as a part of the entire directing challenge ably steered by Giles Croft, who also directed the Broadway production.

Truth is, this is a full ensemble play at its core; everyone is not only involved in character, but to support the story as props and musicians. The two most elegant and touching scenes they have are where kites are flown in a ritualistic, poetic presentation. There is also a gorgeous set of kite representations onstage that are used as a kind of combination curtain and backdrop to separate the scenes out, arriving onstage like a giant butterfly. Wind effects, background noise, all are offered up by the marvelous ensemble here. 

Ramzi Khalaf is a wonderfully effective Amir and does the really difficult task of narrator/actor a great justice. Shahzeb Zahid Hussain as Hassan grabs you hard and eloquently in his character’s vulnerability and loyalty. As the well-to-do merchant Baba, Haythem Noor is both menacing and vulnerable in trying to find a way to identify with the son Amir.  As Soraya, Awesta Zarif is properly reserved at first, only to finally open up to Amir in that awkward, loving way that all youth discovers love.  The entire experience here is poignant and moving. And shocking. And just what theatre, in my eyes, should be. It’s not at all like humming a tune from a musical, but leaving the theatre in a thoughtful mood.  

GUEST CONTRIBUTOR | RONALD KEATON received an Equity Jeff Award for the performance of his one-man show CHURCHILL. www.solochicagotheatre.com  Coming soon, his new solo play “Echo Holler.” www.echoholler.com

PHOTO|Bekah Lynn Photography

Broadway in Chicago
presents
The Kite Runner
CIBC Theatre
through June 23, 2023

TICKETS

TOUR WEBSITE

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC