PicksInSix Review: Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812 - Writers Theatre

‘GREAT COMET’— Big, Bright, Beautiful Star!
PicksInSix® Review | Ed Tracy

The Chicago premiere of “Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812” is lighting up the Glencoe sky over Writers Theatre in a soaring production directed and choreographed by Katie Spelman with music direction by Matt Deitchman. Spelman has assembled an exceptional ensemble who deliver a flawless performance of Dave Malloy’s groundbreaking electropop opera that received a dozen 2017 Tony Award nominations.

There is a lot to unpack in this love story derived from a 70-page section of Tolstoy’s War & Peace. The first path of two storylines that are destined to intersect involve the emotional struggles of Natasha (Aurora Penepecker) a free-spirited young woman who is visiting Moscow to meet relatives of her soldier fiancé who is away at war. Natasha becomes wildly tempted by the deceptive Anatole (Joseph Anthony Byrd) whose seductive charms compel her to break her engagement and make plans to elope with Anatole. But there is more to Anatole than meets the eye.

The second path involves the unhappily married Pierre (Evan Tyrone Martin) who is tormented by drink and depression and searching for his own way out of the situation. Pierre’s promiscuous wife Hélène (Bri Sudia) happens to be Anatole’s sister and takes macabre pleasure in helping him lure Natasha’s affection. Pierre is lost in his own obsessions to the point where he publicly confronts one of Hélène’s lovers, Dolokhov (Andrew Mueller), who also happens to be a friend of Anatole, and, in a drunken rage, challenges him to a duel.

Natasha’s host and godmother Marya D (Bethany Thomas), Natasha’s cousin Sonya (Maya Rowe) and Mary (Julia Wheeler Lennon) Andrey’s sister have vastly conflicting interests while, at home, Mary must contend with the eccentric Bolkonsky (Rob Lindley) and keep a watchful eye on Natasha as events unfold. By the time Andrey (Matthew C. Yee) arrives, there is glass all over the floor and only with Pierre’s influence can there be a hopeful solution for both Natasha and for himself.   

This glorious work is sung-through, a highly ambitious undertaking that could only be accomplished with the superb ensemble—including those mentioned with Sophie Grimm, Will Lidke and Jonah D. Winston—steeped in seasoned Chicago talent and showcasing many fine newcomers to Writers, including the luminous Penepacker whose voice and presence as Natasha is intoxicating in a big, bright, beautiful star turn. Rowe is perfect as Sonya, particularly in the memorable “Sonya Alone.” Martin’s brilliant vocal range is on full display as the conflicted Pierre. Winston has the reins well in hand in “Balaga” leading the company on a wild crowd-pleasing ride.

The creative team of scenic designer Courtney O’Neill, costume designer Raquel Adomo, sound designer Eric Backus and lighting designer Yael Lebetzky create a stellar, unified experience, and the magnificent work of Dietchman, conductor/pianist Charlotte Rivard-Hosler and the orchestra shines brightly all night long to deliver Malloy’s complicated and intricate score with elegance and precision. Altogether, it’s a compelling, cosmic adventure that just might be a once-in-a-lifetime event!

PHOTO|Liz Lauren

Writers Theatre
presents
Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812
through October 27

WEBSITE

TICKETS

PROGRAM

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

PicksInSix Review: Ernest Shackleton Loves Me - Porchlight Music Theatre

Awakening Adventure Awaits If You Frigidaire.
PicksInSix® Review | Guest Contributor | Scott Gryder

The chilling atmospheric wind sounds and shadowy aquas across the stage of the Ruth Page Center for the Arts were all too familiar to Chicago audiences at Porchlight Music Theatre’s opening night performance of “Ernest Shackleton Loves Me.” The ship of a set, ice-locked within a bleak Brooklynite kitchen, quickly let us know that a 90 minute quest for adventure and danger was soon to begin.

The dream-like hallucination that is “Ernest Shackleton” combines the mundane struggles of out-of-work electronic music composer Kat with the over-the-top epic tale of 20th century Antarctic explorer Ernest Shackleton. Like two chaotic glaciers passing in the night, their stories collide at paralleling pivotal points of survival for each. While Kat’s circumstance might not be so life-threatening, the unlikely pair team up to face life’s unexpected trials to the tune of Kat’s music. Driven by her unique blend of stylings, Ernest and Kat venture forth to battle physical and emotional odds, conquering their fears, facing their losses and finding themselves along the way.

Seemingly most challenging for a production like “Ernest Shackleton” would be the casting. The sheer scope of talent required to meet the musical demands of playing a multitude of complex instruments and map through unmelodious music was most likely as nearly insurmountable as the “impenetrable” mountains that Shackleton’s crew had to face. But Porchlight’s Michael Unger and Eric Svejcar have done just that. Elisa Carlson’s Kat is spunky and full of defiance, with a musical mood to match that of pop superstar P!nk. Carlson has the punk-rock edge of a stereotypical 90’s New York avant-garde artist layered with the scratchy vocals of Miley Cyrus. Marry that airy tone with the crispness of Andrew Mueller’s tenor and the quality is full and moving. Together, they vocally sail toward their destination with a keen optimism. But it’s Mueller’s shining acting chops that deliver the emotional strength within the scenes. Not only does he delight when dabbling in and out of dating app characters, but his presence as Ernest Shackleton is grounded in awareness, personality and honest discovery, a discovery that is somewhat lacking in Carlson. Mueller brings us a Shackleton with profound optimism and a thirst for adventure comparable only to that of the fabled Don Quixote.

“Ernest Shackleton” is not your typical musical theater musical. Brendan Milburn’s music is baked in synthetic sound, looping tools, and echoes. Along with this less than traditional style, Val Vigoda presents more patter-based, organic lyrics, versus something more strongly singable. Not that the music and lyrics detract from the storytelling, they simply take a few beats to adjust to. The piece’s pacing, filled with the vigorous wit of Joe DiPietro’s book, rides this hurricanic cutting electronic edge, weaving through the mosaic plot. The essence of “Ernest Shackleton” is reminiscent of a Second City sketch, with its blizzard of puns and predictable situational comedy; however, the full scope of the show is quite charming.

Scott Davis’s scenic sails standing at full mast are serene and captivating, boldly bearing Smooch Medina’s wash of location projections and G. Max Maxin IV’s aurora borealis lighting, amidst his unnervingly cluttered hybrid home/studio made up of trunks and toys, instruments, and instrumentation. The use of the large screen TV in Kat’s kitchen was a bit jarring, but it provided an entertaining canvas for Mueller’s many momentary comedic characters and stunning actual film clips of Shackleton’s expedition. The most monumental creative feat was audio engineer Lynsy Folckomer’s maestro-like balance between the massive waves of electronic sound and amplified gabby lyrics.

The refreshing message delivered throughout the expeditions of “Ernest Shackleton” is the constant reminder to never lose our sense of adventure nor to forget the power of hope, even as we grow up. “Ernest Shackleton” is a playful romp, pushing the envelope of musical stylings and overflowing with talent. If you’re looking for adventure, catch this show soon, for “Ernest Shackleton Love Me” is forced to leave port on June 1st.

GUEST CONTRIBUTOR | SCOTT GRYDER received a Non-Equity Jeff Award for his performance in the one-man show BUYER & CELLAR. www.thescottgryder.com

PHOTO|Liz Lauren  

PORCHLIGHT MUSIC THEATRE
presents
ERNEST SHACKLETON LOVES ME
Ruth Page Center for the Arts
through June 1, 2023

WEBSITE

TICKETS

HEALTH & SAFETY

DIGITAL PROGRAM

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC