PicksInSix Review: Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812 - Writers Theatre

‘GREAT COMET’— Big, Bright, Beautiful Star!
PicksInSix® Review | Ed Tracy

The Chicago premiere of “Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812” is lighting up the Glencoe sky over Writers Theatre in a soaring production directed and choreographed by Katie Spelman with music direction by Matt Deitchman. Spelman has assembled an exceptional ensemble who deliver a flawless performance of Dave Malloy’s groundbreaking electropop opera that received a dozen 2017 Tony Award nominations.

There is a lot to unpack in this love story derived from a 70-page section of Tolstoy’s War & Peace. The first path of two storylines that are destined to intersect involve the emotional struggles of Natasha (Aurora Penepecker) a free-spirited young woman who is visiting Moscow to meet relatives of her soldier fiancé who is away at war. Natasha becomes wildly tempted by the deceptive Anatole (Joseph Anthony Byrd) whose seductive charms compel her to break her engagement and make plans to elope with Anatole. But there is more to Anatole than meets the eye.

The second path involves the unhappily married Pierre (Evan Tyrone Martin) who is tormented by drink and depression and searching for his own way out of the situation. Pierre’s promiscuous wife Hélène (Bri Sudia) happens to be Anatole’s sister and takes macabre pleasure in helping him lure Natasha’s affection. Pierre is lost in his own obsessions to the point where he publicly confronts one of Hélène’s lovers, Dolokhov (Andrew Mueller), who also happens to be a friend of Anatole, and, in a drunken rage, challenges him to a duel.

Natasha’s host and godmother Marya D (Bethany Thomas), Natasha’s cousin Sonya (Maya Rowe) and Mary (Julia Wheeler Lennon) Andrey’s sister have vastly conflicting interests while, at home, Mary must contend with the eccentric Bolkonsky (Rob Lindley) and keep a watchful eye on Natasha as events unfold. By the time Andrey (Matthew C. Yee) arrives, there is glass all over the floor and only with Pierre’s influence can there be a hopeful solution for both Natasha and for himself.   

This glorious work is sung-through, a highly ambitious undertaking that could only be accomplished with the superb ensemble—including those mentioned with Sophie Grimm, Will Lidke and Jonah D. Winston—steeped in seasoned Chicago talent and showcasing many fine newcomers to Writers, including the luminous Penepacker whose voice and presence as Natasha is intoxicating in a big, bright, beautiful star turn. Rowe is perfect as Sonya, particularly in the memorable “Sonya Alone.” Martin’s brilliant vocal range is on full display as the conflicted Pierre. Winston has the reins well in hand in “Balaga” leading the company on a wild crowd-pleasing ride.

The creative team of scenic designer Courtney O’Neill, costume designer Raquel Adomo, sound designer Eric Backus and lighting designer Yael Lebetzky create a stellar, unified experience, and the magnificent work of Dietchman, conductor/pianist Charlotte Rivard-Hosler and the orchestra shines brightly all night long to deliver Malloy’s complicated and intricate score with elegance and precision. Altogether, it’s a compelling, cosmic adventure that just might be a once-in-a-lifetime event!

PHOTO|Liz Lauren

Writers Theatre
presents
Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812
through October 27

WEBSITE

TICKETS

PROGRAM

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC

MotherFreakingHood! Sara Stotts

If only children came with a user manual there might be fewer twists and turns along the journey.

But then again, no birthing guide could produce the kind of hilarious observations that co-writers Sara Stotts and Julie Dunlap have realized in the hilarious musical “MotherFreakingHood!” now playing at Mercury Theater Chicago’s intimate Venus Cabaret.

They were college roommates who took an interest in writing songs together. Then, several years – and, at last count, seven children – later, they were inspired to turn real-life maternal experiences into a free-wheeling, fun-filled musical comedy about motherhood. 

Co-writers of MotherFreakingHood! (l-r) Julie Dunlap and Sara Stotts and director Heidi Van.

The show first debuted in 2013 in Lawrence, Kansas with Dunlap directing and Stotts in the cast. With director Heidi Van and a new cast on board, the show moved on to Kansas City in 2015, was a featured selection in the New York Musical Festival in 2017 and played to sold-out houses at The Blackbox Theater in Kansas City last fall.

The show is now playing at Venus Cabaret where the top-flight Chicago-based cast includes Jacqueline Jones, Leah Morrow, Tafadzwa Diener and Maya Rowe in a fast-paced musical comedy about friendship and child-rearing. 

Sara Stotts joined the CONVERSATION shortly after the show opened to talk about the production from the moment of theatrical conception. PODCAST

Conception: “Well, it all started with my co-writer Julie Dunlap. We were at a significant birthday of mine – let's just say there's a couple digits in it and they're not small. Anyway, we had friends and family there… friends of mine from Second City, from when I was doing the Second City, they had created a band called “Listening Zoo.” They sing all original songs about funny stuff. Like “Darn you Tom Hanks for making me cry again!” All really funny and we had a wonderful time. And then at some point after the party, I got a call from Julie saying, “You know, we could write funny songs about motherhood.” And I thought she was still drunk, quite honestly, because that's just insanity… So, a few months later, songs just started coming out of me. I mean, I just was barfing out songs while I'm brushing my teeth in the bathroom. I called Julie and I said, “You know, Julie… I don't know if you were serious about this, but I've kind of started writing some songs. She says, “I've written three songs!” and it was on.”

Truth in storytelling: “All of the songs are absolute truths. One of the sayings about doing improv is truth and comedy. You know, it's funny because it's true. I mean, we're not making this stuff up. Some stories are a little bit embellished for comedic purposes, but it's based on true stories. That's why it's so relatable to mothers because they've lived it, they've gone through it and we're just putting a funny lens to the absurdities of motherhood.”

The beating hearts of the show: “It's about three women who get pregnant and one's a first-time mom, Rachel, who's terribly excited to get pregnant. And she's so naive and she has no idea what she's getting into, and therefore she's excited. The second mother is Angie. She's had a baby… right on time and she's going to have another baby and it's going to be a girl because she already had a boy and everything goes for her as planned. The third mother, Marsha, she had three kids. She was ready to send her daughters through high school and college. She was not planning on this at all. And she's, let's say, cantankerous. She thought she was done. She thought she would get to retire.” 

The early years: “We first put it up in Lawrence, Kansas. That's where Julie lives. She directed it. And I got to play the role of Marsha… We did rewriting and then we were picked up by a production company to do a production in Kansas City in 2015. At that point, we picked up Heidi Van, who is our current director. She lives in Kansas City. And she could relate totally to the show because she has two kids. She's a mom and her comedic timing is insane. What she does, not just with our script, but the action, the physical funniness of it… she's brilliant!... we were selected to go to New York City for the New York Musical Festival which was a huge honor… after that we wanted to bring it to Chicago in 2020, but I don't know if you've heard of the musical called “The Pandemic?” Yeah. That ran for a long time… and occupied every theater. So, we had to put it to bed for a while. … Heidi has a theater in Kansas City called The Black Box Theater and we did 10 shows. Sold out. It was great! Great reviews. We won an award from Broadway World for the Best New Musical in the Kansas City region. That was an honor! From there, we made it to the Venus Cabaret Theater here in Chicago.”

Cast of MotherFreakingHood! at Mercury Theater Chicago (l-r) Jacqueline Jones, Tafadzwa Diener, Maya Row and Leah Morrow.

Chicago cast: “They are just so hilarious. The way they connect with the audience… they are so comfortable. We've got Tafadzwa Diener playing Rachel, the young mom. We've got Jacqueline Jones playing Angie the second time, mom… Leah Morrow, who's playing Marsha the third time mom and then we have Maya Row playing the “Every Woman” character. She plays multiple different characters throughout. It is so fun to see them bring these characters alive. Every production's going to be different. Every actor is going to interpret it their own way and bring their own brilliance to it. This cast is having so much fun and there is so much fun coming out of the audience.”

Not just for the moms: “We get great reactions from dads. When we did the Kansas City Show, it was funny because my husband came out of the bathroom at intermission as says: You should hear what the reviews are like in the men's bathroom. These guys are loving it!” We always get good reactions from the guys because we don't exclude the men who made us mothers. We never say anything bad about it, but men go through the same things. The men go through the same absurdities. We are just telling it from our lens as women, but they get a huge kick out of it. They can relate.”

The impact of the show on personal and professional lives: “It makes you appreciate your family more. I do get a little mom guilt because I was already busy and now I've made myself busier… I'm sure my kids would love for me to be home a little bit more… what I love is that my kids' first musical experience in New York City was seeing “MotherFreakingHood!” and I just got a kick out of that. It wasn't “Rent” it was “MotherFreakingHood! That just gave me a, a huge kick. They have been really supportive and I think it's good for them to see we're making fun with them. We're not making fun of them, we're making fun with them.” PODCAST

Excerpts have been edited for length and clarity.

PRODUCTION PHOTOS| Liz Lauren

Mercury Theater Chicago
presents
Chicago Premiere
MotherFreakingHood!
A Musical Comedy

Venus Cabaret
3745 N. Southport Ave
through June 11, 2023

Tickets
(773) 360-7365

Official Show Website

For more reviews, visit: Theatre In Chicago

ARCHIVE

PicksInSix® is a registered trademark of Roxbury Road Creative, LLC